Home » Homemade Candy

Homemade Fudge | 5‑Ingredient-Simple

homemade fudge with nuts on a white platter
Post may con­tain affil­i­ate links. See my Affil­i­ate Disclosure.

Home­made Fudge is a hol­i­day tra­di­tion I can get behind! Among all the Christ­mas cook­ies and can­dies set out on our dessert table, there will always be a plate of rich, but­tery fudge at the cen­ter. This recipe makes a creamy, deeply-choco­late fudge that melts in your mouth. And, it uses NO marsh­mal­low creme.

My mom was the champ of good old fash­ioned boiled fudge. Deli­cious! The gold stan­dard of choco­late deca­dence. It’s a vivid and won­der­ful child­hood mem­o­ry. Alas, I have nev­er mas­tered that tech­nique. And after years of try­ing, I switched to a method that works for me. 

This easy Home­made Fudge recipe still does­n’t have the boiled fudge tex­ture that I love. It is soft­er, like marsh­mal­low creme fudge, but with­out hav­ing to have the marsh­mal­low fla­vor. It’s my favorite alter­na­tive to tra­di­tion­al boiled fudge for both fla­vor and for sim­plic­i­ty. With only 4 or 5 pantry ingre­di­ents, you’ll be able to eas­i­ly cre­ate this dreamy choco­late con­fec­tion for your own hol­i­day gift­ing and treats. 

It’s fast and it’s sim­ple. You can make it ahead and freeze it. (instruc­tions in recipe card) You’ve def­i­nite­ly got to try this. Let’s make some sweet choco­late satisfaction!

The Ingredients

Semi-Sweet Choco­late Chips: You could use milk choco­late if that’s your pref­er­ence, but this deli­cious home­made fudge is already pret­ty rich. If you have real­ly good bak­ing choco­late on hand, you could break that up and use it, too. You’ll need a total of 36 ounces.

Sweet­ened Con­densed Milk: Not evap­o­rat­ed milk. You’d be sur­prised how many peo­ple con­fuse those two, though they are VERY dif­fer­ent things. Sweet­ened con­densed milk has sug­ar added and is cooked down until it is thick and creamy, almost caramel. Cook it a lit­tle longer and it WILL become caramel. Evap­o­rat­ed milk is sim­ply milk with the milk solids con­cen­trat­ed by evap­o­rat­ing some of the water.

But­ter: I don’t think it makes a dif­fer­ence in this recipe, but I always buy salt­ed but­ter. So, that’s what I use in my fudge.

Vanil­la: I make my own vanil­la extract, but if you have a favorite high qual­i­ty vanil­la you can def­i­nite­ly use that.

option­al: Nuts — We love pecans or wal­nuts, but choose your favorite. If you have aller­gies or don’t like them, just leave out the nuts.

An Easy DIY Double Boiler

Using two pans to make a DIY double boiler.

If you have a dou­ble boil­er, by all means use it. But, if you don’t, it in no way pre­vents you from mak­ing this recipe or any oth­er can­dy recipe that calls for one. 

A dou­ble boil­er is essen­tial­ly one pan sit­ting over anoth­er. The top pan is heat­ed by the steam from boil­ing water in the bot­tom pan. It cre­ates a much gen­tler heat that is per­fect for melt­ing and tem­per­ing choco­late or mak­ing curds and cus­tards. You can make a DIY dou­ble boil­er at home with­out buy­ing spe­cial equipment.

You’ll need two pans. The top pan should fit just inside the rim of the bot­tom pan. It’s impor­tant that the boil­ing water in the bot­tom pan nev­er touch­es the bot­tom of the top pan, so choose pans that will allow enough of a gap between the two.

Any two stack­able pans will work as long as the top pan sits sta­bly over the top of the bot­tom one. Add one to two inch­es of water to the bot­tom pan. Bring the water to a boil and set the sec­ond pan inside the upper rim of the first pan. 

Now, add ingre­di­ents to the top pan and pro­ceed as the recipe instructs. Magic!

How to Make Homemade Fudge

homemade fudge

This may be one of the sim­plest can­dy recipes you’ll ever make.

Spray two 8x8 pans or one 9x13 pan. Then line them with foil leav­ing enough of an over­hang to lift the fudge out of the pan when it has set up.

Put the con­densed milk, choco­late chips, vanil­la and but­ter into the top pan and set that over the pan with the boil­ing water.

Allow the choco­late and but­ter to ful­ly melt, stir­ring to incor­po­rate all the ingredients. 

The mix­ture will be smooth, thick and glossy when it is done. It will only take a few minutes.

Pour the fudge into your pre­pared pan and use a spat­u­la to spread it to an even thick­ness. I fold the foil over­hangs in to some­what cov­er the fudge while it is in the refrigerator.

Refrig­er­ate for at least 1 hour. Use the foil to lift your home­made fudge out of the pan. Cut the block of can­dy into small squares and arrange on a plat­ter or can­dy dish for serving. 

You should get at least 36–48 (prob­a­bly more) pieces of fudge, depend­ing on the size of squares you cut. It’s very rich, so small pieces of fudge are usu­al­ly bet­ter than large ones.

The Recipe

Print
clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon
homemade fudge

Homemade Fudge


  • Author: Glen­da Embree
  • Total Time: 15 min­utes
  • Yield: 36–48 pieces of fudge

Description

Creamy, rich­ly choco­late deli­cious­ness!  Home­made fudge is so sim­ple to make and is one of those tra­di­tion­al hol­i­day treats that shows up in gift bas­kets and on all the best hol­i­day dessert tables.  Don’t reserve it just for Christ­mas, though.  It’s sweet choco­late sat­is­fac­tion all year long.


Ingredients

  • 2 (14 oz.) cans sweet­ened con­densed milk

  • 3 (12 oz.) bags semi­sweet choco­late chips

  • 1/2 cup but­ter

  • 1 Table­spoon home­made vanil­la (or your favorite com­mer­cial brand)

  • option­al, 1 cup chopped nuts (We pre­fer wal­nuts or pecans. Use what you love or leave nuts out, altogether.)


Instructions

  1. Prep 2 (8x8 or 9x9) square pans by light­ly spray­ing them and then lin­ing each pan with plas­tic wrap.  ( You could also use a 9x13 pan, but for stor­age pur­pos­es, the square pans work more eas­i­ly, for me.) 
  2. Make the strips of plas­tic wrap long enough to hang out of the pan and be able to wrap back over the top, again, lat­er.  The plas­tic wrap will help lift the fudge from the pan when it’s done, but it will also cov­er and wrap the fin­ished fudge.  So be sure to use long enough strips.
  3. Use a dou­ble boil­er, or if you’re like me and don’t have one, place one pan over anoth­er or a large heat-proof mix­ing bowl over a pan.  The bot­tom pan should have 1 or 2 inch­es of water in it.  Bring it to a boil and reduce the heat to just keep it boil­ing but not evap­o­rat­ing dry.  The water should be at least one-inch below the bot­tom of the mix­ing bowl.  You nev­er want it to touch.  The steam is what will melt your chocolate.
  4. Add all ingre­di­ents, except the nuts, to the mix­ing bowl.  Heat and stir until the choco­late is com­plete­ly melt­ed and all ingre­di­ents are able to be ful­ly incorporated.
  5. Add the nuts and stir to dis­trib­ute them evenly.
  6. Pour the mix­ture into the pre­pared pan and pull the extra plas­tic wrap up over the top to cov­er the pan.
  7. Refrig­er­ate until the fudge has set and is firm.
  8. Lift the fudge out of the pan and cut into small pieces.
  9. Serve.

Notes

How to Freeze Fudge:

Fudge can be frozen, if you plan to make it in advance.  The secret is to wrap it care­ful­ly, first.

Once you have removed the block of fudge from the pan, prep it for freez­ing BEFORE cut­ting.  Com­plete­ly wrap it in plas­tic wrap.  Next, wrap it in foil and seal the edges tight. 

Insert the wrapped block of fudge into a gal­lon-size zip-top freez­er bag.  Remove any air from the bag as you seal it shut.  Now, you can freeze your fudge safe­ly for up to 6 months.

You can store indi­vid­ual pieces of home­made fudge in the same way, if you like.  It def­i­nite­ly makes it easy to remove them just a piece or two at a time.  I, per­son­al­ly, don’t usu­al­ly like to take the time to wrap indi­vid­ual pieces, so I freeze the entire block and cut it after thawing.

How to Thaw Frozen Fudge

Leave the wrap­pings in place and set the block of fudge in the refrig­er­a­tor.  You want to make sure the fudge retains its mois­ture, so don’t remove the wrap­pings until it is com­plete­ly thawed.  Once the fudge has com­plete­ly thawed allow it to set out at room tem­per­a­ture for 20 min­utes.  Care­ful­ly remove the wrap­pings and cut to serve.  It should be as won­der­ful as when it was fresh­ly made.

  • Prep Time: 5
  • Cook Time: 10
  • Cat­e­go­ry: Dessert, Can­dy
  • Method: stove top
  • Cui­sine: Amer­i­can

Key­words: choco­late, fudge

More Great Holiday Treats

8 thoughts on “Homemade Fudge | 5‑Ingredient-Simple”

Leave a Comment

Recipe rating