Waffle Iron Turtle Cookies (with Gluten Free Option)

Waf­fle Iron Tur­tle Cook­ies are fudgy, sat­is­fy­ing deli­cious­ness. They’re so sim­ple to make and since you bake them in a waf­fle iron, you nev­er heat up your kitchen to cre­ate them. 

The name comes from the unique shape the waf­fle iron gives the cook­ies. But stay tuned. I’ll show you a caramel pecan vari­a­tion to give them true “tur­tle” fla­vor. Look for that under the pic­ture tuto­r­i­al at the bot­tom of the page. 

My mom taught me to make these sim­ple cook­ies as a kid. I’ve tweaked the frost­ing a bit since then, but they’re still the same amaz­ing cook­ie I remem­ber from childhood.

Every time I pull the recipe out again, I won­der why it’s tak­en me so long to bake anoth­er batch. I love them. My fam­i­ly loves them. I’ve actu­al­ly nev­er met any­one who does­n’t. If you love fudgy choco­late and easy cook­ies, this will be your new favorite recipe!

The Ingredients

Anoth­er great ben­e­fit of using this recipe is that it calls for every­day pantry ingre­di­ents. I don’t need to make a gro­cery run before I can make Waf­fle Iron Tur­tle Cookies.

If you often bake gluten free, then you’ll rec­og­nize the Bet­ter Bat­ter Gluten Free Flour Blend I used to make this par­tic­u­lar batch of Tur­tle Cook­ies. To make the recipe gluten free, sub­sti­tute the same amount of Bet­ter Bat­ter in place of the all pur­pose flour. It’s that easy! *

To make both the cook­ies and some fudgy frost­ing, here’s what you’ll need:

• But­ter
• Cocoa Pow­der — This is the unsweet­ened bak­ing cocoa pow­der, not hot choco­late mix.
• Eggs
• Sug­ar
• Vanil­la
• Flour (All pur­pose flour for a reg­u­lar batch. If mak­ing gluten free, I rec­om­mend Bet­ter Bat­ter Gluten-Free Flour Blend. It’s what I used to make this batch and gives good con­sis­tent results with cookies.)
• Milk
• Pow­dered sug­ar (con­fec­tion­er’s sugar)

How to Make Waffle Iron Turtle Cookies

As always, you can just run with this recipe and bake your­self into a sat­is­fy­ing choco­late fudge hap­py place. How­ev­er, if you’re a visu­al learn­er and want to see how this recipe comes togeth­er, scroll down for the pic­ture tuto­r­i­al. You’re gonna love Waf­fle Iron Tur­tle Cookies!

How to Make Original Turtle Cookies

1. Start by heat­ing up your waf­fle iron. The cook­ie bat­ter comes togeth­er in about 5 min­utes, so hav­ing the waf­fle iron hot and ready gets you bak­ing, quickly.
2. Put the cocoa pow­der and but­ter into a 3 quart saucepan and melt them togeth­er over medi­um heat. Stir as you heat the mix­ture. Only keep the butter/cocoa mix­ture on the heat long enough to just melt the but­ter. Remove the pan from the heat as soon as the but­ter’s melted.
3. Mix the sug­ar and vanil­la into the butter/cocoa mix­ture. Mix­ing it will help to cool it even fur­ther. The goal is for it to just be warm to the touch. 
4. Add the eggs and mix them in thor­ough­ly. Mix in the flour until you have a thick bat­ter the con­sis­ten­cy of brown­ie batter.
5. Drop 4 spoon­fuls of bat­ter at a time into the hot waf­fle iron. Bake the cook­ies for 1 minute and then remove them to a cool­ing rack. Repeat until all the bat­ter is used.
6. Make the frost­ing by melt­ing the sug­ar and but­ter togeth­er in a 3 quart saucepan. 
7. Remove from the heat and add milk vanil­la and pow­dered sug­ar. Use a hand mix­er to blend the ingre­di­ents and cre­ate the fudge frosting.
8. Frost the cook­ies. The frost­ing will firm up as the cook­ies sit.

A Tasty Caramel Pecan “Turtle” Variation

I was mak­ing these cook­ies for a gath­er­ing of 30 peo­ple, this week. I decid­ed to dress them up and make them tru­ly “tur­tle” by adding pecans and caramel before the frost­ing. I have to say, it was a smash­ing suc­cess. I f you want to give this tur­tle cook­ie update a try, before frost­ing the cook­ies, add these steps.

1. Sprin­kle the cen­ter of your baked cook­ies with chopped pecans. 
2. In a microwave-safe bowl, melt two 11 oz. bags of Kraft Caramel bits with 2 Table­spoons of milk. It took just 2 min­utes on high-pow­er in my microwave, so keep a close eye on them.
3. Once melt­ed, spoon the caramel over the cen­ter of each cook­ie, cov­er­ing the pecans. (I did­n’t get a pic­ture of that step for some rea­son, but it’s pret­ty self-explana­to­ry. You’ve got this!
4. When the caramel has cooled and set up, frost the cook­ies as direct­ed in the recipe.

Tools I Used to Make Waffle Iron Turtle Cookies

• Waf­fle Iron _{[affil­i­ate link]} I use a stan­dard waf­fle iron, not a Bel­gian waf­fle mak­er. The spaces would be too large in a Bel­gian waf­fle maker.
• Hand Mix­er _{[affil­i­ate link]} You could mix up the frost­ing by hand, but you’ll get a smoother creami­er con­sis­ten­cy using a mixer
• Cool­ing Racks _{[affil­i­ate link]}

These are sure to become a fast fam­i­ly favorite! I hope you get a chance to make Waf­fle Iron Tur­tle Cook­ies to share with your favorite peo­ple, soon. If you do make them and find you love them as much as I and my fam­i­ly, please con­sid­er stop­ping by here to leave a com­ment with a 5 star rat­ing. Those 5 star rat­ings help oth­ers find our recipes when doing a Google search. Thanks for being so sup­port­ive and awe­some! Hap­py Baking!

The Recipe

Print

More Chocolate Recipes to Try

Chocolate Crinkle Cookies

Homemade Chocolate Pudding

Easy No-Bake Cookies